Guest Stars Jennifer Siebel as Jennifer Conover William Atherton as Mickey Rayborn Shashawnee Hall as Special Agent Paul Bodner Brianne Davis as Erika Hutton Mary Mouser as Carin Sutter Marcus Giamatti as Dave Harris Kyle Gallner as Zak Sutter Steven Crowley as Clay Co Starring Emily Evan Rae as Kid #1 Bonnie Hellman as Nadine Bill Lee Brown as Man at Podium Justin Wren as Kid #2 Kai Schmoll as Counter Clerk Monica Lee as Mother Uncredited Piper Moretti as Aunt