Guest Stars William Smillie as Officer Geoff Cobb Abraham Benrubi as Pete McCann Daniel MacPherson as Scott Murphy Marlene Forté as Mita Co Starring Nathaniel Buescher as Mateo Murphy Dawn Hasbrouck as Reporter Tosin Morohunfola as Vet Rachel Cerda as Alisa Will Zahrn as Pharmacist Jimmy Fierro as Jed Baxter Kelson McAuliffe as Ryan Sanders Ava Silva as Emily Jimenez