Guest Stars Genelle Williams as Rachel Sutton Michael Xavier as Logan Jonsen Pascal Langdale as Karl Marsten Fiona Highet as Karen Morgan James McGowan as James Williams Paulino Nunes as Antonio Sorrentino Sherry Miller as Olivia McAdams Joel Keller as Peter Myers Marc Bendavid as Scott Brandon Kaitlyn Leeb as Amanda Co Starring Noah Cappe as Travis Rogan Christopher as Deputy Paul O'Neil Evan Buliung as Braxton Chris Ratz as Jack Peter Jorgensen as Creepy Hipster Ryan Long as DJ