Guest Stars Laura Benanti as USPIS Agent Edie Max Casella as Joe Delicious Mamoudou Athie as Carl Jeffrey Vincent Parise as Carlos Catrina Ganey as Judge Westlake Co Starring Meredith Handerhan as Stenographer Suzie Cho as Mrs. Lieberman Henry Stram as INS Agent Richardson Kenneth De Abrew as Raju Souleymane Sy Savane as African Man Adam Smith Jr. as Desk Clerk Obaid Kadwani as Arab Man Hope Mackenzie Perry as 12-Year-Old Vanessa Tessa Skara as Beckany Daniel Velasco as Delivery Guy