Guest Stars Tracy Spiridakos as Detective Hailey Upton Markie Post as Barbara "Bunny" Fletcher Esai Morales as Chief Lugo Nora Dunn as Doctor Lonnie Richardson David Aaron Baker as Jeremy Pettigrew Lucas Kerr as Craig Gorman Bret Tuomi as Alan Metcalf Co Starring A.C. Smith as Superintendent Darren Stephens as Male White Shirt Elaine Rivkin as Female White Shirt Eunice Woods as Janice Hendricks Ashley Noel as Cynthia Robbins Mickey O'Sullivan as Jake Harper Briana Smith as Beth Murphy C.J. Rush as Kirby Jeff Christian as Sheriff Johnny Lester Walter S. Bernard as Elijah Hendricks