Guest Stars Callie McClincy as Holly Holter Melinda McGraw as Patricia McCready Charmin Lee as Rose Giles Pete Burris as Ogden Julia Crockett as Sarah Barnes Madelyn Deutch as Dakota Toby Huss as Owen Boyd Hoon Lee as Dr. Kenneth Park Briana Venskus as Officer Nunez Gabriel Michael Bateman as Joshua Austin Susan May Pratt as Helen Devere Co Starring Adam Vernier as Officer Tuttle Lacy Camp as Betsy Austin Asher Miles Fallica as Young Kyle Jennifer Gatti as Churchgoer #1 Lindsley Register as Churchgoer #2 Greta Glenn as Vella Mark Scarboro as Churchgoer #4 Timmy Sherrill as Paul Austin Pat Keenan as Churchgoer #3