Guest Stars Boris McGiver as Robert Goddard Brennan Brown as Robert Treat Paine Brett Gentile as Jail Guard Mark Jeffrey Miller as Rope Walker / Wharf Local Vincent Renart as Andrew Holmes Michael Hall D'Addario as Young Charles Adams Melissa Blue as First Mourner Jim Carmalt as First Boston Local Chris Clabo as Secound Mourner Jimmy R. Fowler as Apprentice's Father Roxanne Fox as Female Slave Justin Phillips as Apprentice / Heckler Rose Powhatan as Third Mourner Mike Shiflett as Fourth Mourner Justin Smith as First Rope Walker Christopher Monroe Stokes as Apprentice / Heckler Sam Trueman as Apprentice / Heckler Charles Wise as Third Boston Local Michael Tourek as Second Wharf Local Joe Hickey as Customs Man Tom Beckett as Elbridge Gerry Isaac Esau Gay as Second Boston Local Tripp Green as Matthew Kilroy Dara Coleman as James Forrest Robert X. Golphin as Male Slave William Yelton as Apprentice / Heckler Quentin Kerr as Court Clerk Cheyenne Casebier as Esther Sewall Madeline Taylor as Young Nabby Adams Steven Hinkle as Young John Quincy Adams Harry Zittel as Hugh Montgomery John Joseph Gallagher as Jury Foreman Bill Buell as Justice Lynde