Guest Stars Arjun Gupta as Sam Stephen Wallem as Thor Lundgren Gbenga Akinnagbe as Kelly Slater Cristin Milioti as Monica Danny Hoch as Mr. Digby Co Starring Lenny Jacobson as Lenny Katie Flahive as Paramedic Guthrie Nutter as David Bonvino Douglas Taurel as John Bonvino Donshea Hopkins as Little Girl Anya Marlene as Social Services Eugene Michael Santiago as Orderly Eddie Schweighardt as Bennet Walter Hudson as Priest