Guest Stars Ted Whittall as FBI Special Agent Reynolds Annie Ilonzeh as Beth Blair Redford as Zach Victoria Profeta as Leslie Phelan Co Starring Kirsten Comerford as Kim Pisano Laura Cilevitz as Sue Daniela Barbosa as Gabriella Brandon Thomas as Officer Wilton Brittany Kay as Cocktail Waitress Lamont James as Officer #2 Ramzi Ayash as Gabe's Assistant