Special Guest Stars John Lithgow as Arthur Mitchell Guest Stars Christina Robinson as Astor Bennett Preston Bailey as Cody Bennett Courtney Ford as Christine Hill Rick Peters as Elliot Larson Mary Mara as Valerie Hodges Eve Mauro as Attractive Woman Greg Ellis as Jonathan Farrow John Griffin as Timothy Marisa Petroro as Kate Cooper Huckabee as Joe Nix Mark Atteberry as Attorney Bill Doyle as Father