Guest Stars Morena Baccarin as Dr. Leslie Thompkins Chelsea Spack as Kristen Kringle David Zayas as Sal Maroni Charlie Tahan as Jonathan Crane / Scarecrow Philip Hernández as Dr. Guerra Maria Thayer as Scottie Mullens Julian Sands as Gerald Crane Lillias White as Bible Woman Brian Keane as Boat Captain Co Starring Aaron Marcus as Tightly Wound Man Robert McKay as Sergeant Joe Tuffy Questell as Duffy Jim Ford as Adam Jodowsky Dwelvan David as Pirate