Guest Stars Maggie Geha as Ivy Pepper Anthony Carrigan as Victor Zsasz Charlie Tahan as Jonathan Crane / Scarecrow Damian Young as Warden Reed Michael Maize as Grady Harris Co Starring Ken Straus as Desk Sergeant Jared Johnston as Thief #1 Clem Cheung as Apothecary Owner Ramon Nuñez as Thief #3 Matthew R. Staley as Lunatic #3 Mickey Jaiven as Thief #2 Dwight "Scorp" Waugh as Clown Apparition Tom Martin as Lawyer Goldwyn Banton as Powerful Man