Guest Stars Martin Cummins as Tom Keller Lochlyn Munro as Hal Cooper Robin Givens as Sierra McCoy Hayley Law as Valerie Brown Asha Bromfield as Melody Valentine Brit Morgan as Penny Peabody Jordan Calloway as Chuck Clayton Co Starring Alvin Sanders as Pop Tate Cameron McDonald as Mr. Svenson Tony Todd as Farmer McGinty Christiaan Westerveld as Slender Man June B. Wilde as Waitress Gina Stockdale as Older Women Barclay Stiff as The Criminologist