Special Guest Stars Brad Garrett as Ron Getman Guest Stars John Siciliano as Harrison Cara Buono as Amaya Andrews Joe Holt as Kellan King Corey Allen as Abel Bekele Ben Thompson as Jeff Hill Co Starring Dereje Tarrant as Caleb Houston Adrienne D. Williams as Judge Harper Nnamudi Amobi as Neighbor Terrence Shingler as Man in Suit Jeff Williams as Juror 10 Alina Cho as Daytime Talk Show Host Jake Soister as Officer of the Court Mirirai Sithole as Naomi Shara Ashley Zeiger as Juror 7 Holly Lisker as Juror 5