Guest Stars Martin McCreadie as Captain Doyle David Wilmot as Capt. Connor Daisy Bevan as Esther Jackson Gann as Joseph / Bernadette Josef Altin as Willem Van Bergen Grace Zabriskie as Mrs. Moore Sean Young as Mrs. Van Bergen Peter McRobbie as Mayor Lafayette Strong Stephen Louis Grush as Jesse Pomeroy Co Starring Sean McGinley as Bishop Potter Geoffrey Thomas as Roberts Tommy Rodger as Peter Laurel Lefkow as Mrs. Isaacson Bálint Adorjáni as Delmonico's Waiter David Warner as Professor Cavanaugh William Gaminara as Alexander MacLeod Dániel Kanalas as Moore's Brother William S. Todd as Prison Guard Colin Moody as Officer Lasky Ania Marson as Miss Effie Lewis McGowan as Boot Black