Guest Stars Deirdre O'Connell as Gaby Ali Ahn as Nicole Patch Darragh as Russel Armstrong Sarita Choudhury as Lilith Asan Titus Makin, Jr. as Caleb Matthews Daisy Eagan as Pastor Jones Co Starring Kevyn Morrow as Reverend William Matthews Philip Hernández as Doctor Costa Jo Lampert as Jeremy Devyn Inez Fusaro as Sky Raja Burrows as Dee Susannah Schulman Rogers as Linda Locke Wendy Rich Stetson as Doctor Siegel Erin Glass as 4R