Guest Stars Annie Wersching as Emma Whitmore Susanna Thompson as Carol Preston Tonya Glanz as Jessica Michael Rady as Nicholas Keynes Sofia Vassilieva as Abiah Franklin Emily Swallow as Bathsheba Pope Henri Lubatti as Judge John Hathorne Patrick Fischler as Joseph Pope Todd Weeks as Judge Samuel Sewall Co Starring Jennifer Marshall as Mary Esty David Wells as Wardwell Jennifer Christopher as Alice Parker Shiloh Nelson as Betty Sewall Dylan Rourke as Barkeep Sally Berman as Martha Cory Preston Acuff as Jailer