Guest Stars Aida Turturro as Judge Felicia Catano Bronwyn Reed as Lucy Huston Jefferson Mays as Dr. Carl Rudnick Susie Essman as Counselor Arlene Heller Jaden Matthew Rodriguez as Gil Mancheno Hari Dhillon as Counselor Sunil Varma Christine Toy Johnson as Dr. Celia Lee Emily Dorsch as Hannah Schwartz Missi Pyle as Trudy Malko Julie Lauren as Mia Biel Marla Sucharetza as Mrs. Harrington Hayden Tweedie as Savannah Biel David Margulies as Dr. Eric Setrakian Co Starring Stephen C. Bradbury as Judge Colin McNamara Tony Campisi as Counselor Steve Roth Kate MacCluggage as Colleen Dole Lois Robbins as Jillian McAdams Cliff Samara as Jury Foreperson Dante Bruzzese as Larry Heller Dante Palminteri as Leo McAdams Evan Daves as Gabriel Dole Jack Garrity as Michael Boylan Jackson Stenborg as Jaden Boylan Joy Lynn Pringle as Chloe Harrington Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration