Special Guest Stars Gil Birmingham as Sheriff Bishop Guest Stars Sarah Jane Redmond as Elaine Pownall Sedale Threatt Jr. as Levi Aylya Marzolf as Katrina Ron Yuan as Aldon Decker Jill Teed as Widow McClure Co Starring Hannah Levien as Janine Tammy Gillis as Deputy Marissa Staub Sarah Hayward as Sylvia Heather Feeney as Beachcomber #3 Cameron McDonald as Beachcomber #1 Mike Wasko as Beachcomber #2 Ron Robinson as Deputy #1 Serena van Rooy as Little Girl Jai Braithwaite as Sylvia's Date