Guest Stars Jemar Michael as Al Lucas Nia Jervier as Kelsey Phillips Caitlin Carver as Muffy Tuttle Diamond White as Penelope Tyler James Williams as Carson Rhodes Co Starring Nicholas Anthony Reid as James Dickerson Sheridan Pierce as Abigail Jeffrey Larson as White Student #1 / Gordon Anthony Ma as Dave Ellysa Rose as Amy Fortune Feimster as Christine Halberg Eric Johnson as Carver Coleman Daniel Monaco as Max Ydaiber Orozco as Nurse Jennifer Agyapong as Jeanette