Guest Stars Rachel Bay Jones as Susan Shazi Raja as Jaya Francesca Ling as Parker Eleanor Koski as Liv Flor De Liz Perez as Natalie Daniella Rabbani as Rabbi Zoe Christopher Redman as John Dove Zachary Gemino as Tibetan Boy Tara Pacheco as Receptionist Melvin Mogoli as Barista Kyle Harris as Matthew James Gino Cafarelli as NYPD Officer Emily Jackson as Stacie Jonathan Sale as Preacher Elliot Santiago as Bodega Owner Andrew Kaempfer as Driver