Guest Stars Ed Begley Jr. as Older Justin Ryan Hansen as Mid-Life Justin Edward James Gage as Officer Co Starring Tyra Colar as Buyer #1 Hardy Awadjie as Buyer #3 Matthew Atherton as Father Elizabeth Sandy as Mother Thom Shelton as Pizza Guy Richie Cottrell as Brother 1 Tyler Kaplan as Brother 2 Elena Crevello as Molly Kristen Lapari as Buyer #2