Guest Stars Anjali Bhimani as Dr. Rasgotra Pamela Reed as Mary Bidwell Abigail Zoe Lewis as Young Sandra Austin Kane as Young John David Bidwell Clint Carmichael as Sam Bidwell Christopher May as Rodney Tanner Braden Fitzgerald as Hunter Olson Billy Dec as Detective Paul Rosado Tatiana Szalay as Ann Olson John Henry Cabula as Nolan Alvardo Britain Dalton as Billy Hawkins Gregg Rogen as Mr. Parker Brenda Kate as Mrs. Parker Travis Gibson as Jake McCauley Kelly Fitzgerald as Lyla Olson Anson Bagley as Joshua Parker Ephraim Burns as Tyler Phylicia Wissa as Marjorie Terence Bernie Hines as Stanley Holmes Michael Hyland as Phil Olson J. Michael Trautmann as John David Bidwell Cornelius Jones Jr. as Desmond Shannon Lorance as Sandra Bidwell