Guest Stars Daniel Nemes as Gavin Kacey Rohl as Marina Andrieski (Timeline 23) Jewel Staite as Phyllis Tom Wright as Nick / Santa Claus Jolene Purdy as Shoshana Ryan McDonald as Bacchus Zach Cherry as Frankie Gallo Co Starring West Duchovny as Whitley Matthew Nelson-Mahood as Jay Tara Pratt as Branch Manager Evelyn Ian Butcher as Lionel Nalani Wakita as TV Crew V.G. Winter as Agent Sharmaine Yeoh as Woman with Puppies Colin Cowan as Ice Cream Dude Deborah Ramsay as Beatrice McAllister Colin Foo as Roman