Guest Stars Anne Dudek as Benedicte Schaeffer Michael Rispoli as Wilkie Dino Rende as John Schaeffer Kyle Bornheimer as Paul Joey Auzenne as Diego Rodriguez James Quinn as Medical Examiner Dorothy Silver as Mrs. Steinmetz William Gines as LaShawn Dredan McFall as Trevor Stewartson Keith Michael Gregory as Patrick Albright Pete Postiglione as Eric Reed Annie Fitzpatrick as Neighbor CJ Ramirez as Dr. Fenton Charles David Richards as Priest Chris Bellant as Undergrad Dan Lemieux as Kevin Steinmetz Mark Mazzocco as Boyd Taylor Fedak Stephen Lee Anderson as Clide Fedak