Special Guest Stars Gilbert Gottfried as Joey Mellman Guest Stars Charlie Brill as Capt. Harry Lipschitz John O'Hurley as Dr. Scott Waverly Kehli O'Byrne as Tonya Jodi Taffel as Ellie Otis Kathrin Middleton as Valarie Lehman Christopher Mayer as Paul Jaeger Donna Baltron as Cindy Dann Co Starring Avalon Anders as Girl in Gym