Guest Stars Jeff Perry as Mike O'Neil Sprague Grayden as Tonia Sells Damon Gupton as Investigator Dennis Luken Patrick Gallagher as Detective Dave Nissley Josh Randall as Officer Mitrovich Jenna Lamia as Laurel Alan Ruck as John Dzialo Toni Torres as ADA Ana Guerra Co Starring Hannah Barefoot as Melissa Jonathan Craig Williams as Paul Avery Kristen Pohl as Kelly Julia Prud'homme as Kate Blake Connor Tillman as Deputy Lisa Mason Lee as Concierge