Guest Stars Clare Carey as Sarah Parker Alex Carter as Sheriff Logan Parker Marcus Coloma as Father Tomas James Morrison as Kingston Nickson Jon Hamm as Dr. George Forrester Neil Hopkins as Preston Hodges Co Starring Marnie Crossen as Mrs. Havelock Greg Fawcett as Local Rubber-Neck #1 Zadran Wali as Local Rubber-Neck #3 Christopher Hoffman as Municipal Worker Ken Garcia as Local Rubber-Neck #2 Scott Rankin as Daniel Deborah Vancelette as Mother Deanna Driscoll as Mercy Withers C.S. Keys as Bartender