Special Guest Stars Bobby Cannavale as Angie "AJ" Geils Jr. Guest Stars Matthew Glave as Joe Perry Heather Graham as Diane Duran Gina Torres as Gillian Kayhill Jake Picking as Emerson Lake-Palmer Carl Reiner as Glen-Allen Mixon Co Starring Nikki Boyer as Sherry Netherlands Sarah Cortez as Desk Clerk Michael Hyland as Jeremy Gride Ryan Windish as Bartender Bill Lippincott as Mr. Kayhill Alvarez Ricardez as Willie Dustice Thomas Daniel Smith as Security Guard