Guest Stars Matt Hobby as Pastor Jeff Hodgkins Melissa Peterman as Brenda Sparks Ryan Phuong as Tam Nguyen Rex Linn as Principal Tom Peterson Brian Stepanek as Mr. Hubert Givens Isabel May as Veronica Duncan Katherine Von Till as Anchor Travis Guba as Pete Co Starring Nick Alvarez as Derek Jordan Leer as Bryan Jack Seavor McDonald as Jared Tiffany Jeneen as Shopper #1 Susan Grace as Older Woman Jay Brian Winnick as Shopper #2 K.J. Powell as Kid #1 Sebastian Armani as Kid #2