Special Guest Stars Blair Brown as Emma Roderick Guest Stars Alex Appel as FBI Agent Janey Cooper Aaron Ashmore as Colin McNeil Michael Riley as Steven Dawson Co Starring Cheyenne Chung as Young Nicole Scott Tony Munch as George Maiser Spencer Van Wyck as Ryan Olivia Ballantyne as Karen Tracey Ferencz as Harried Mom Jillian Rees-Brown as Foster Mom