Special Guest Stars Timothy Dalton as Dr. Niles Caulder / The Chief Guest Stars Mark Sheppard as Willoughby Kipling Julie McNiven as Sheryl Trainor Curtis Armstrong voices Ezekiel the Cockroach Lilli Birdsell as Martha / Mother Archon Ted Sutherland as Elliott Patterson Jeanette O'Connor as Marilyn Ezra Buzzington as Dr. Bertrand Co Starring Skye Roberts as Kay Challis Chantelle Barry voices Baphomet Orelon Sidney as News Reporter Michael Scialabba as Todd / Father Archon Swift Rice as Ferdinand Tyler Buckingham as Frank Drew Ater as Chaz Lauren Richards as Nina Casey Hendershot as Skinhead #1 Thiree Pinnock as Cheesesteak Josh Diogo as Skinhead #2 Cate Jones as Young Marilyn Guilherme Apollonio as Billy