Guest Stars Nina Kiri as Alma / Ofrobert Bahia Watson as Brianna / Oferic Edie Inksetter as Aunt Elizabeth Ashleigh LaThrop as Natalie / Ofmatthew Sugenja Sri as Sienna John Ortiz as Jim Thorne Emily Althaus as Noelle Ian Ho as Ryan Co Starring Angela Vint as Leah Paula Boudreau as Grace Scott Tasha Attey as Amber Marissa Kate Wilson as Ofzachary's Partner Samantha Parkinson as Handmaid Michelle Chiu as Handmaid Kelsey Falconer as Ofandy Raevv'n Leedham as Handmaid Michelle Mohammed as Handmaid Maythaila Jerome Antoine as Handmaid Stefanie Nakamura as Coat Check Woman Lara Mrkoci as School Security Guard Sarah Marchand as Handmaid Daveed Louza as CPS Agent Catherine De Sève as Mrs. Allston Karen Jewels as Karaoke Singer Sophia Smith as Handmaid Sarah Slywchuk as Red Center Handmaid Claudia Jurt as Red Center Aunt