Guest Stars Matthew Glave as Oscar Hutchinson Sarah Shahi as Jessica Russo Kurt Yaeger as Graham Ross Sean Maher as Caleb Jost Dohn Norwood as Deacon Joe Tamara Braun as Elizabeth "Beth" Ohlsen Chido Nwokocha as Marcos Gibson Reggie Watkins as Keon Co Starring Jon Snow as Deputy Finn Nickerson Jeannie Epper as Aunt Sallie Austin Rising as Lewis Boone Platt as Darrell Roberto Montesinos as Hector Alfred Adderly as Wounded Deputy Eddie Diaz as Sheriff's Deputy Reece Rios as Steven Bernstein Ray Huizar as Valet