Guest Stars Caitlin Mehner as Heather Husband Candice Coke as Wren Catherine Lidstone as Isabel Sanchez Tiffany Dupont as Nikki Castro David Alpay as Dylan Elaine Hendrix as Susan Alders Shanesia Davis as Irene Boudreau Brett Rice as Charles Lynch John Cothran, Jr. as Pastor White Frank Collison as Dr. Winkler Nishi Munshi as Sarah Bukhari Co Starring Ben Marten as Brian Husband Abby Blankenship as Ben's Girlfriend Thomas Gaitsch as Judge Bryant Andy Nagraj as Nasher Elias Andrew Ritter as Male Pro-Life Protestor #2 Rom Barkhordar as Kasim Bukhari Anita Chandwaney as Dina Bukhari Ryan McBride as Ben Bollinger Craig Spidle as Senator Thurston Black Joseph Anthony Byrd as Chaz Holly Gombita as Female Pro-Life Protestor #1 Paloma Nozicka as Deputy Prosecutor Janice Molina