Guest Stars Caitlin Mehner as Heather Husband Laurie Holden as Greta Bellows David Alpay as Dylan Jeffrey Nordling as Rick Zahn Bryce Pinkham as Connor Mayfeld Brett Rice as Charles Lynch Jim True-Frost as Arthur Kaufman Victoria Park as Adele Meyerson Karin Anglin as Tessa Meyerson Co Starring Casey Tutton as Rosemary Lynch James Farruggio as ASA Duncan Ben Marten as Brian Husband Heidi Johanningmeier as Linda Barrett James Krag as Joe Welch Patrick Clear as Clarence Meyers Eddie Diaz as Evan Esteban-Miller Seb Torgus as Young Toby Kissell Will Zahrn as Judge - M&L Trial Sean Michael Sullivan as Carter Leopold Abby Pierce as Cassie Lintz Julian Josip as Young Clint Jeff Kurysz as Grant Thargard Kyle A. Gibson as Clint Parsons Krystle Cousins as Foreperson Vincent Kracht as Minister Rae Lindenberg as Young Cassie Kate Fry as Doctor Reed Kylan Conroy as Sydney Ball Marsha Estell as Judge Luisa Rosati April Sutton as Angry Inmate William Dick as Jamie Evans