Guest Stars James Lesure as FBI Agent Jim Turner David Hornsby as Leslie "Boomer" Peterson Caleb Emery as Baby Tyler Allison Tolman as Mary Pat Sally Pressman as Nancy June Squibb as Marion Peterson Brad Morris as Principal Clark Lauren Stamile as Gretchen Zorada Co Starring Braxton Bjerken as Kenny Boland David Miranda as Marcus Kue Lawrence as Benji Noah Salsbury Lipson as Andy Ian Sharkey as Billy