Special Guest Stars Jim Beaver as Apocalypse World Bobby Singer Guest Stars Erica Cerra as Dumah Co Starring Wolsey Brooks as Wounded Refugee Hunter Catherine Lough Haggquist as Detective Glass Giles Panton as Harrison Tate Xantha Radley as Shelley Kurt Long as Pastor Ames Kareem Malcolm as Prayer Group Member Dean Monroe McKenzie as Eremiel Grace Chin as Prayer Group Member C. Douglas Quan as Prayer Group Member Shawn Bordoff as Prayer Group Member John Gillich as Prayer Group Member Josh Chambers as Wraith Carolyn Tinglin as Prayer Group Member