Guest Stars Ethan Maher as Sami Ben Ahlers as Liam Aimee Carrero as Sofia Lopez Nadine Nicole as Amy Bowman Katrina Lenk as Claire Danville Guy Lockard as Gordon Paul Ben-Victor as Angelo Napolitano Tyler Jacob Moore as Deacon Hailey Kilgore as Olivia LaChanze as Wendy Parker Co Starring Gabrielle Hespe as Fake Gwendolina