Guest Stars Wallace Shawn as Dr. John Sturgis Matt Hobby as Pastor Jeff Hodgkins J. Doc Farrow as Wayne Wilkins Brian Stepanek as Mr. Hubert Givens Nancy Linehan Charles as Peg Danielle Pinnock as Ms. Evelyn Ingram Mary Grill as Robin Co Starring Heather Olt as Waitress Michael C. Alexander as Greg Melanie Haynes as Felicia Credit Only Zuleyka Silver as Selena