Guest Stars Natalie Hall as Lucy Craig Parker as Alastair Caine Valerie Cruz as Marisol Vera Virginia Williams as Charity Callahan Leah Pipes as Fiona Callahan Constantine Rousouli as Hunter Caine Jessica Steen as Devorah Silver Karin Konoval as Elder Robinson Co Starring Chiara Guzzo as Trishelle Meghan Drew as Barback #1 Dan Ginnane as Barback #2 Aliesha Pearson as Blonde Woman Jennifer Oleksiuk as Cate Monroe Kelsi Chartrand as Elder Wade Andrea Ross as Elder Connor Jinsook Ko as Elder Chen Michelle C. Smith as Elder Zaragoza