Guest Stars Zoe Margaret Colletti as Benedetta Rohr Mark Ryder as Father Diarmuid Doyle Catherine Wolf as Rose Congemi Sarah Shahi as Rachel Benham James Michael Cummings as Tommy Hayes KeiLyn Durrel Jones as Andre Benjamin Seth Gilliam as Reverend Jasper Fields J. Bernard Calloway as Captain Shag Lewis Lee Tergesen as Vito "The Pig" Lupo Haviland Morris as Kate Southworth Leland Fowler as Maurice Jones Co Starring Blake Baumgartner as Kick Ryan Grayson Eddey as Tony Ryan Nora Murphy as Marie Ryan Charles MacLean as Scott Hook Lucas Van Engen as Sheik Sheehan Akim Black as Leonard Jensen MaYaa Boateng as Kayla Wiley Joe Gioco as Judge Leo Tirone Alma Cuervo as Female Juror Joseph Castillo-Midyett as Technician David J. Cork as Male Juror Charlie Fersko as Billy Starla Benford as Mable Kane Curzon Dobell as Clerk Magistrate Katt Masterson as Woman on Payphone Michael Erik as Male Student
