Guest Stars Laura Benanti as Quinn Tyler Phoebe Dynevor as Clare O'Brien Michael Urie as Redmond Willa Fitzgerald as Audrey Colbert Nicole Ari Parker as Beth Co Starring Chinasa Ogbuagu voices Podcast Narrator Abra Tabak as Woman #1 Dominique Allen Lawson as Liquor Store Attendant Luther Creek as Tim Kelvin Whui as Chinese Businessman Robert King as Young Dad #3 Nemuna Ceesay as Woman #2 Donald Chang as Young Dad #1 Mike Holt as Young Dad #2