Guest Stars Austin Stowell as Lieutenant Theodore Cole Juliana Canfield as Nina Bowman Kerry Bishé as Mary Ann Whitaker Edward Burns as Bill Kaminski Duncan Joiner as Elijah Whitaker Co Starring Erika Coleman as Pauline's Nurse Jay DeVon Johnson as Police Chief McClarty Henry Bazemore Jr. as Deputy Sheriff #2 Susan Williams as ER Nurse Michael Chandler as Sheriff Parker Andrew Benator as Milburg Desmond Phillips as Deputy Sheriff #1 Aly Ward Azevedo as Teenage Girl on Phone Martha Bird Knighton as Pauline Alicia Roberts as TV News Anchor Derek McDonnell as Male Nurse