Guest Stars Sasha Alexander as Paula Porter Dylan O'Brien as Sam Taylor Victoria Pedretti as Evelyn Porter Micah Stock as Jake Taylor Cullen Douglas as Henry Barrett Gabriel Olds as William Co Starring Nandy Martin as Francesca Garrett Kruithof as Shopkeeper Michaela Russell as Mildred Brian Matney as Grandfather Warren Daryn Kahn as Photographer O'Bryan Neely as Bartender of Speakeasy Luke Speakman as Little Sam