Guest Stars Madison Wolfe as Audrey Hart Dana Gourrier as Cathleen J.D. Evermore as Det. Lutz Kevin Dunn as Major Ken Quesado Joe Chrest as Det. Demma Dane Rhodes as Det. Favre Anthony Molina as Detective Alexandra Daddario as Lisa Tragnetti Meghan Wolfe as Macie Hart Michael Harney as Steve Geraci Don Yesso as Commander Speece Christopher Berry as Danny Fontenot Alyshia Ochse as Lucy Jay O. Sanders as Rev. Billy Lee Tuttle Brad Carter as Charlie Lange Clarke Peters as Pastor Jason Kirkpatrick as Deputy Davi Jay as Gordon DiCillo Jennifer Dawson as Erath Woman Charleigh Harmon as Anette Ron Clinton Smith as Sheriff Tate Charley Vance as Erath Man Wanetah Walmsley as Janet Fontenot