Guest Stars Matt Gordon as Thomas Hope Tanner Stine as Clay Boone Tara Rosling as Esther Miller Genevieve Kang as Patty Yang Will Chase as Simon Coles Zack Pearlman as Glasses Co Starring Gabriel Darku as Zach Jaymes Rachel Wilson as Iris Julia Knope as Brenda Gasser Paula Rivera as Ms. Aguilar Taylor Jackson as Rachel Reha Sandill as Amna Téa Helena Carini as Susannah Shaquille James-Holsten as Jason Thom Marriott as Isaiah Angela Asher as Fran Catherine Thomas as Teacher Brianne Tucker as Mennonite Singer F #5 Samantha Parkinson as Mennonite Singer F #4 Gabrielle Prata as Mennonite Singer F #1 Michael Kash as Mennonite Singer M #5 Lawrence Ross Cotton as Mennonite Singer M #1 Steven Ambrose as Mennonite Singer M #2 Chris Chinchilla as Mennonite Singer M #3 Kenneth Baker as Mennonite Singer M #4 Owen McCausland as Mennonite Singer M #6 Josh Ross as Mennonite Singer M #7 Jordan Collalto as Mennonite Singer M #8 Frances Townend as Mennonite Singer F #2 Stacie Dunlop as Mennonite Singer F #3 Caitlin Emily McCaughey as Mennonite Singer F #6 Amanda Weatherall as Mennonite Singer F #7
