Guest Stars Shawn Ashmore as Wesley Evers Matthew Glave as Oscar Hutchinson Sarah Shahi as Jessica Russo Jasmine Mathews as Rachel Hall Enver Gjokaj as Donovan Town Lizze Broadway as Aurora Dayo Ade as Jonathan Ryland Jim Ortlieb as Judge Stevens Rico E. Anderson as Amari Co Starring Crystal Coney as Nurse Lisa Carsyn Rose as Lila Town Jon Snow as Deputy Finn Nickerson Debbie Fan as Doctor Tyler Quinlan Abbott as Pierce Greg Bryan as Tow Driver Michelle Castillo as Maria Reyes Diane Reneé as Bailiff Giovanni Bejarano as José Reyes Lamar Usher as Lewis Patrick Hume as Counterfeit Guy