Guest Stars Matt Gordon as Thomas Hope Tanner Stine as Clay Boone Tara Rosling as Esther Miller Michelle Nolden as Wendy Jacobson Will Chase as Simon Coles Angel Giuffria as Zoe Shohreh Aghdashloo as Fatima Co Starring Carina Battrick as Young Henry Coles Laura Miyata as Elaine Kido Paula Rivera as Ms. Aguilar Jennifer Wigmore as Mrs. Linderman Howard Hoover as Pastor Robert Jacobson