Special Guest Stars Janet Leigh as Miss Diketon Guest Stars Letícia Román as Pia Monteri Jack Palance as Louis Strago Allen Jenkins as Enzo "Pretty" Stilletto Jack La Rue as Federico "Feet" Stilletto Eduardo Ciannelli as Arturo "Fingers" Stilletto Joan Blondell as Mrs. Fingers Stilletto Co Starring Elisha Cook as Arnold Penny Santon as Grandmama Monteri Maxie Rosenbloom as Crunch Battaglia Ludwig Donath as Dr. Von Kronen Vince Barnett as Scissors Clarke Gordon as Officer Frank Puglia as Padre Francisco James Almanzar as Thrush Captain Jesslyn Fax as Mrs. Feinberg James Bates as Boy Charles Victor as 1st Passenger Vincent Beck as Luger David Renard as Donkey Man Warren Parker as 2nd Passenger Sharyn Hillyer as Miss Gorgeous Uncredited Leoda Richards as Wedding Guest Philo McCullough as Retirement Home Resident Arthur Tovey as Townsman Cosmo Sardo as Wedding Guest Bobby Gilbert as Parade Spectator / Wedding Guest Jeffrey Sayre as Parade Spectator Anthony Redondo as Thrush Agent Frank Baker as Retirement Home Resident Albert Cavens as Wedding Guest Lars Hensen as Thrush Agent Jimmie Horan as Ticket Taker Jack Tornek as Wedding Guest Caryl Lincoln as Wedding Guest